The golden rule of reporting: Say vs. tell

English has two main reporting verbs that can be used when reporting what was said. If you’re learning how to use reported speech, these are the first verbs you should master. These verbs are say and tell. Though they are similar in form, their grammatical usage differs. It’s quite easy to understand the difference between the two verbs:

  • say emphasizes the information
  • tell needs an audience

Verb

Structure

Reported speech examples

say

say + something

 She said she was tired.

say

say + something + to + someone

 She said to me that she was tired.

tell

tell + someone + something

 She told me she was tired.

Notice that tell must be followed by a person.

She told she was tired.

She told me she was tired.

This single rule prevents one of the most common B1-level mistakes.

What is reported speech?

Reported speech (also known as indirect speech) is how we convey or repeat the saying, thinking, questioning or feeling that someone has expressed. Instead of using the sentence directly, we communicate the idea in our own words. This usually requires alterations in pronouns, tenses, time references and sentence structure.

Direct speech:

 Jake said, “Our flight has been delayed.”

Reported speech:

 Jake said that their flight had been delayed.

In reported speech, the use of quotation marks is eliminated, and the statement is incorporated into another statement.

How does reported speech differ from direct speech?

The major difference between the two lies in the fact that direct speech includes an actual quote from a person, while reported speech expresses the same message indirectly without quoting the exact words.

Direct speech

Reported speech

 “I accidentally sent the email to the CEO,” Michael said.
 Michael said that he had accidentally sent the email to the CEO.
 “We’re getting married next spring!” Maya announced.
 Maya announced that they were getting married the following spring.
 “This cake contains a secret ingredient,” the chef said.
 The chef said that the cake contained a secret ingredient.
 “I saw a fox riding a skateboard this morning,” Liam claimed.
 Liam claimed that he had seen a fox riding a skateboard that morning.
 “Our flight has been delayed for six hours,” the airline agent said.
 The airline agent said that their flight had been delayed for six hours.

Do you see how the meaning does not change, but the sentence structure is different? It happens because pronouns, verbs, and temporal indicators change.

Level up your English with Koto!

The 3 pillars of reported speech: Transformation rules

In reported speech grammar, we do more than simply remove quotation marks. We move the entire sentence into a new context.

Your friend says something on Monday and you report it on Tuesday. The sentence that you quoted comes from a different time, from a different speaker, and usually from a different location. There are thus three aspects that are commonly changed:

  • The tense shifts backward.
  • The pronouns shift perspectives.
  • The time and place expressions are adapted.

Let us examine each element separately.

Step 1: Tense backshift

The first one refers to the change in verb tenses in English. If the statement was uttered in the past, its initial present form becomes the past in the reported speech B1.

Direct speech

Reported speech

 “I work remotely.”
 He said that he worked remotely.
 “I am working.”
 He said that he was working.
 “I have finished.”
 He said that he had finished.
 “I will call you.”
 He said that he would call me.
 “I can help.”
 He said that he could help.

The most frequent tense transformations are the following:

Direct speech

Reported speech

Present Simple

Past Simple

Present Continuous

Past Continuous

Past Simple

Past Perfect

Present Perfect

Past Perfect

Modal verb shift

Some modal verbs also change when you convert direct speech into reported speech. The most common changes are:

Direct speech

Reported speech

 will
 would
 can
 could
 may
 might
 must
 had to(for obligation)

When is the backshift in reported speech not necessary?

We maintain the original tenses when the reported statement:

  • is introduced by a reporting verb in the present:  He says that he is ready.
  • when the statement expresses a fact that is still true:  The teacher said that water boils at 100°C.

Step 2: Pronoun change

The second change relates to point of view. If a person uses I, the pronoun tends to be changed when a second person relates the sentence.

Direct speech

Reported speech

 “I lost my keys,” Sarah said.
 Sarah said that she had lost her keys.
 “We are moving,” the couple said.
 The couple said that they were moving.
 “My car is new,” Tom said.
 Tom said that his car was new.
 “I sent you the file,” Anna said to Jack.
 Anna told Jack that she had sent him the file.

An important question is: Who is speaking now? The answer will dictate the personal pronouns used.

Step 3: Time and place expressions

The last rule involves modifying words related to time and place. If the original speaker used tomorrow, that tomorrow may already be in the past by the time you report it.

Direct speech

Reported speech

 now
 then
 here
 there
 today
 that day
 tomorrow
 the next day
 yesterday
 the day before

Now let’s see how all three reported speech rules apply.

Direct speech:

 Jane said, “I will finish the report tomorrow.”

To convert this into reported speech, we need to do three things:

Step

Change

Result

1. Tense backshift

will → would

 I would finish the report tomorrow.

2. Pronoun change

I → she

 She would finish the report tomorrow.

3. Time expression change

tomorrow → the next day

 She would finish the report the next day.

Reported speech:

 Emma said that she would finish the report the next day.

The above example indicates the basic idea of reported speech: the sentence is perceived differently, from another angle in time. Due to this, it becomes necessary to alter the verbs, pronouns, and time expressions simultaneously.

Or even more visually:

reported speech grammar

The second version appears to be a small tutorial that explains the rationale behind each change.

How to report different types of sentences

Not only are statements used in reported speech, but we can also report questions, orders, and other forms of speech. It is vital to understand the structure of each English reported speech form.

Reported speech statements

Reporting statements are the simplest form of reported speech. One merely needs to introduce the sentence using a reporting verb.

english reported speech form

Direct speech

Reported speech

 “I’m hungry.”
 He said (that) he was hungry.
 “I need help.”
 She told me (that) she needed help.

This is completely natural and very common.

Reported speech questions

This is where students tend to go wrong. Golden rule: The reported question follows the structure of a statement, not a question.

Wh- questions

Keep the wh-word (where, what, why, when, how), but change the structure of the rest of the sentence to the statement form.

Direct question

Reported question

 “Where do you live?”
 He asked me where I lived.
 “Why are you late?”
 She asked why I was late.
 “What does this word mean?”
 The teacher asked what that word meant.

Notice that do/does/did disappear.

Yes/No questions

If there is no question word, use if or whether.

Direct question

Reported question

 “Do you speak English?”
 He asked me if I spoke English.
 “Are you ready?”
 She asked whether I was ready.
 “Can you help me?”
 He asked if I could help him.
reported speech questions

Reported commands and requests

Reported commands (to/not to) follow a different pattern from statements and questions. Instead of using a tense backshift, they undergo an imperative shift. The imperative verb changes into an infinitive (to + verb), making this one of the simplest reported speech structures to learn.

reported commands and requests

Direct speech

Reported speech

 “Open the door!”
 He told me to open the door.
 “Call me later.”
 She asked me to call her later.

For negative commands, use not to:

Direct speech

Reported speech

 “Don’t touch it!”
 He warned me not to touch it.
 “Don’t be late.”
 She told me not to be late.

Top 3 mistakes learners make in reported speech

Even those students who know the rules commit the same three errors. Avoid them, and your reported speech will be much more natural.

Mistake #1: Mixing up say and tell

A common mistake among learners is the incorrect use of say and tell. The truth is that in English, there is a difference between them:

  • say + something
  • tell + someone + something
Incorrect Correct
 My sister said me she got the job.
 My sister told me she got the job.
 The teacher said us to be quiet.
 The teacher told us to be quiet.

Mistake #2: Keeping question word order

Reported questions (if/whether) turn into statements. The interrogative word remains, but there is word order change. Note:

  • No inversion
  • No do / does / did
  • Use statement word order
Incorrect Correct
 She asked me what was my plan.
 She asked me what my plan was.
 They asked why was she late.
 They asked why she was late.

Mistake #3: Backshifting twice

Some students change the auxiliary verb and the main verb. If there is didn’t, the main verb must remain unchanged.

Incorrect Correct
 He said he didn’t went.
 He said he didn’t go.
 She said she didn’t saw him.
 She said she didn’t see him.

Enjoy personalized learning!

Conclusion

Reported speech becomes much easier once you stop treating it as a pile of exceptions. First, choose say or tell correctly. Then shift the tense, adjust the pronouns, and update time and place markers. 

For questions, remember the main trap: use statement word order. For commands, use to + verb. With these patterns and cheat sheets, reported speech and indirect speech turn from grammar fog into a clear route you can follow in real conversations. 

FAQ

Do I always have to use that after said?

No. In everyday English, that is optional and is often omitted, especially in conversation.

What happens to modal verbs like should, would, or must?

Should and would usually stay the same in reported speech. Must often changes to had to when it expresses past obligation.

How do I report a short "Yes" or "No" answer?

Instead of repeating yes or no, English often uses reporting verbs such as agree, refuse, confirm, or deny to express the meaning more naturally.

Does the Past Perfect tense change in reported speech?

Usually not. Since the Past Perfect already refers to an earlier action, it normally remains unchanged in reported speech.